Indian HNIs prefer realty investment in India than abroad

The Indian HNI (high net worth individual) is being aggressively wooed by foreign developers. With the balance of economic power shifting towards Asia, and with India projected to be the world’s third largest economy by 2050, and a subsequent increase in the number of wealthy individuals , property consultants from across the globe are making a sales pitch, and also getting the HNI segment interested enough to buy.

HNIs are people with net financial assets (liquid assets) of at least $1 million, excluding primary residence and consumables. Data from consultants like Cap-Gemini and Merrill Lynch suggests that India has the youngest HNI population in the Asia-Pacific region, with the club having even 28-year-olds on their rolls.

Strong GDP growth, robust figures in industrial and service sectors, high market capitalization , and steady FII inflows are some factors contributing to the rise in HNI wealth. In 2006, India’s HNI population crossed the 1 lakh figure, which made it the second-fastest growing HNI segment in the world, after Singapore, where the growth was 21%.
If one were to analyze the asset allocation of Indian HNIs, data suggests that while equities make up the greatest portion of India’s HNIs’ portfolio at 31%, 17% of their investibles are in real estate.

“If you were to look at the total pie of investment by Indian HNI, only 2% of the investment from Indian HNIs is going in overseas real estate ,” says Samantha Jerath, a director at Jerath Properties, Delhi-based real estate consultant having a portfolio of many HNIs. He adds, “Barring Dubai and London, I do reckon (investment taking place in) any other place due to cultural differences, unfamiliarity with local laws, language issues.”

Also accessing and monitoring one’s investment becomes so much more difficult when it is an overseas investment, as there is paperwork involved, making payments from time to time, and with many real estate investment options available back home with even better appreciation profiles, Indians any day prefer their home country.

Vikram Baidyanath, a HNI, says out of all global property destinations, London is most attractive to him. “I’ve spent more than six years in London and it is more of a second home. Besides , it gives a comfort level to be in London and see our products displayed in famous stores. The Asian community has a strong presence and English is understood and spoken by all, so even language is not a barrier.”

Though well travelled, he feels he would not be exactly tempted to invest elsewhere - “To invest in a foreign real estate, either one has to have business interest in a place that makes you travel frequently to that country or be really attached to that place. Also, the appreciation in property is not all that phenomenal to attract anyone to casually invest in any and every global locale.”

Lack of awareness about foreign projects and foreign laws is another deterrent for HNIs from investing in foreign real estate. According to Sandip Sen of Calcutta Skyline who has a good network of HNI clients in the eastern part of the country, “We have found that Indians are not investing a lot in foreign markets, if at all they are investing, it is restricted to UK and the Middle East. Primary constraints in making overseas property investments include unfamiliarity with local laws of that country, fear of being stuck in litigation in another country, plus lack of awareness in general. Also there are regulatory issues.” As per RBI regulations, the maximum limit allowed in investments outside India is $200,000 per year. For any higher investments , RBI needs to be approached.

Dubai has been a popular choice with Indian HNIs and that is corroborated by Dubai-based real estate consultant Mansoor from Spring Rose Real Estate consultants, “A lot of Indian, especially HNIs from South India are investing in retail, while HNIs from Delhi and Mumbai are purchasing apartments from well established brand names in real estate. As a matter of fact, HNIs from India, Pakistan and Bangladesh like to have a foothold in Dubai due to citizenship , tax rebates etc.”

With recession, property prices have depreciated globally. But this has not translated into attractiveness towards overseas properties. On the contrary, according to Dr Devinder Gupta, CEO & CMD of Century 21 India, “Due to the global meltdown and uncertainty in realty sector, many projects have become unviable. Even bankers are not willing to lend. All this has led to Indian HNI being wary of investing overseas.”

There are enough accounts of developers being faced with credit crunch, globally, who have stalled construction work, delaying most of their projects in the pipeline. Developer’s cash flow problems and credit crunch has in turn impacted delivery deadlines of projects.

Samantha Jerath sums it, “Real estate investment is all about perception, trust, and ease of accessing and monitoring projects.